German Economic Expectations Rebound in November as ZEW Sentiment Index Hits 35.6

Germany's ZEW survey reversed October's decline, but the current-conditions gauge remained firmly negative as the recovery stayed uneven.

Robert Paulsen
Written by Robert Paulsen
Published
Share

German economic expectations recovered in November, with the ZEW Indicator of Economic Sentiment rising 7.5 points to 35.6 after a decline the previous month. The improvement suggested that financial-market experts had become more hopeful about the country’s outlook, even as their assessment of present economic conditions remained negative.

The Mannheim-based research institute reported the results on Tuesday, November 17. Its separate measure of Germany’s current economic situation rose by 2.7 points to minus 33.2. Both indicators improved, but the substantial gap between them shows that confidence in a recovery is still stronger than confidence in the economy’s performance today.

Expectations recover from October’s decline

The expectations indicator had fallen to 28.1 in October, down 6.6 points after gains during the summer. November’s increase not only reversed that setback but left the measure modestly above its September level. The latest reading therefore signals a renewed positive outlook rather than a sudden change in underlying economic activity.

ZEW’s November survey results reflect the views of financial-market specialists asked how they expect economic conditions to develop over the next six months. The headline number is a balance of positive and negative assessments, expressed in points. It is not a forecast that German output will grow by 35.6%, nor does it measure the pace of business activity in November.

ZEW President Achim Wambach described the German economy as remaining on a gradual recovery path. He pointed to rising manufacturing orders and falling oil prices as potential support, while cautioning that government expenditure has been an important driver so far and has raised concerns about the sustainability of public debt.

Those reservations matter because the improvement in expectations has not erased respondents’ dissatisfaction with the current situation. The conditions gauge moved from minus 35.9 in October to minus 33.2 in November. Although that is a second consecutive monthly improvement, a deeply negative balance still indicates that unfavorable assessments outweigh favorable ones.

Differences between industries were also pronounced. Expectations strengthened for chemicals and pharmaceuticals and for the electrical industry, according to ZEW, but deteriorated for metal manufacturing. Construction’s outlook moved further into negative territory. That split suggests the rise in the overall index should not be read as evidence that every major part of the German economy is gaining momentum.

Factory orders offer support, but production remains uneven

Recent official statistics help explain why the November survey became more upbeat without showing a decisive acceleration in activity. Germany’s Federal Statistical Office reported that manufacturing orders increased 4.4% in September from August, after adjustment for seasonal and calendar effects. Orders excluding large contracts rose 5.1%, suggesting the improvement was not solely the result of unusually large individual bookings.

The monthly rebound followed a revised 10.1% plunge in August, however. On a less volatile three-month comparison, manufacturing orders in the third quarter were only 0.2% higher than in the second. Domestic orders increased 6.6% in September and foreign orders gained 2.8%, with orders from other euro-area countries growing faster than those from outside the currency bloc.

Industrial output provides another reason for caution. Price-adjusted production rose 0.7% in September from the preceding month, according to Destatis, but was 0.4% lower for the third quarter as a whole than in the second quarter. Automotive production recorded a strong monthly increase after low output in earlier months, while construction and machinery production declined. The mix is consistent with an economy showing pockets of recovery rather than uniform strength.

Broader growth figures have been positive but restrained. Germany’s gross domestic product increased 0.2% in the third quarter from the previous three months, according to the statistical office’s preliminary estimate released in October. Household and government consumption together edged higher, while capital formation declined and the earlier strong pace of export growth slowed. A rise in business expectations would need to translate into sustained orders, investment and output to produce a more durable expansion.

Price developments add another dimension. Germany’s annual consumer inflation rate eased to 2.8% in October from 3.3% in September, according to final Destatis figures. Yet energy products were still 12.2% more expensive than a year earlier. Falling oil prices may improve the outlook for industrial costs, as Wambach suggested, but lower inflation does not mean that previous increases in household and business expenses have disappeared.

Eurozone sentiment improves as spending questions persist

The better mood extended beyond Germany. ZEW’s eurozone economic-expectations indicator rose 8.0 points to 26.5 in November, from 18.5 a month earlier. Its assessment of current conditions in the currency area was virtually unchanged at minus 14.7, compared with minus 14.8 in October. As in Germany, respondents were more optimistic about the coming months than about the economy’s present state.

The regional improvement is relevant for German manufacturers, whose prospects depend partly on orders from neighboring economies. The September increase in orders from euro-area customers provides some evidence of that connection. Still, the eurozone survey is an expectations measure, not confirmation that demand has already strengthened across the region.

Public spending poses a separate test of the recovery’s durability. Wambach’s comments indicate that fiscal support has played an important role in Germany’s recent progress, but his warning about debt sustainability points to a limit on relying on government demand alone. A stronger private-sector contribution, particularly through business investment and sustained industrial production, would make the improvement less dependent on fiscal support.

The next detailed reading of German third-quarter GDP is scheduled for November 25, when Destatis is due to publish a fuller breakdown of economic activity. ZEW’s next monthly expectations release is scheduled for December 15. Those reports should help distinguish a lasting improvement in confidence from a temporary recovery in November’s survey balance.

Robert Paulsen

About the author

Robert Paulsen

Personal Finance Writer

Robert Paulsen writes about personal finance choices involving spending, saving, debt, insurance and long-term goals. With more than a decade of financial-writing experience, he focuses on the trade-offs that determine whether a common rule actually suits a household.

View author profile